A referee might be selected for expertise in only one area, for example to judge if a statistical analysis is appropriate, or if a particular technique that is essential to underpin the conclusion has been undertaken properly. What is the meaning of "decision in process" status? Experiments gone wrong? How, when, and why you should appeal an editor's decision - Cell After review, Nature Communications rejected it because of reason X. resubmitnoveltyappeal, Resubmitpoint-by-pointresponse letterresubmitresponse letterresubmitresponse letternature, Proofreadingresubmit, Proofreadinglicence to publish, NatureNatureNature, wileynature science, Nature CommunicationsNatureNature CommunicationsPeer-review, Nature Communicationstransparent peer-reviewgetNature Communicationsget50%Nature Communicaitons, sciencenature. Answered by Editage Insights Things just always take much longer than we think they would. Editor decision started might sound like the editor is going to bench reject your paper, but thats not necessarily the case. New referees can often raise new sets of points, which complicates and lengthens the consideration process instead of simplifying it. 9.3 weeks. Authors submitting to Nature do so on the understanding that they agree to these policies. I have been working in the Scientific Publishing Industry for more than 3 years now. editor decision started nature rejection - playtcubed.com Please avoid repeating information that is already present in the abstract and introduction. Is it possible to rotate a window 90 degrees if it has the same length and width? For more information,please refer to our FAQ page. The handbookis available from R Upskill, a sister brand providing learning programs for various aspects of a researchers work, including writing, submission, publication, and research promotion. Which type of forging is used for Flashless forging? The reviewers only make recommendations. How long does an editor decision take? - Studybuff This decision will then be validated by the Editor-in-Chief. Thus, in rejecting an appeal, we do not intend to imply that our initial decision was flawless, only that the arguments for reconsideration were not sufficiently convincing to exceed the deliberately high threshold for reversing a decision. No, Modified on: Fri, 10 Sep, 2021 at 3:16 PM. After going through the reviewers comments, the editor will make a decision about your manuscript. volume5,page 917 (2002)Cite this article. A final decision of acceptance or rejection of the revised manuscript is made by the editors as soon as they conclude that they have sufficient information at hand for doing so. Internet Explorer). Cloudflare Ray ID: 7a2b13d3eec43de7 By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. PIs gone AWOL? The paper is accepted for publication in principle once the authors have made some revisions in response to the referees comments. The criteria for publication of scientific papers (Articles) in Nature are that they: Further editorial criteria may be applicable for different kinds of papers, as follows: Articles published in Nature have an exceptionally wide impact, both among scientists and, frequently, among the general public. You could ask how soon they think they will answer, or give a deadline yourself, warning them that, after that deadline without having heard, you will submit the text to another publisher. In a perfect world, we would consult with dozens of experts, who would spend many hours considering every point in the manuscript. var d=new Date(); yr=d.getFullYear();document.write(yr); The journal editor will probably make their final decision about your paper based on the changes you now make to the work, as well as the contents, its originality, and the way you write your cover letter. Finding reviewers who agree to deal with the . Nature editors will normally honour requests that a paper not be sent to one or two (but no more) competing groups for review. If authors wish to contest an editorial decision, we ask them to submit a form that organizes their arguments into categories that we find useful in reviewing our original judgments. Decisions by editors are routinely made very rapidly after receipt of reports, and Nature offers an advance online publication (AOP) service to an increasing number of manuscripts. The first thing to do when you get a rejection is to take a deep breath and consider your options. Hello. And "wish you the best in your future endeavors" is the rejection letter equivalent of your crush signing "Have a great summer" in your yearbook. Asked by megha m resubmitnoveltyresubmit, 4. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Hope that helps. Rejection is of course a fact of life for all scientists, particularly when they submit their work to highly selective journals; in less than five years since its inception, Nature Neuroscience .