why homestuck is problematic why homestuck is problematic

What Pumpkin, unlike Hasbro, is not a media giant with multiple branches and properties under its wings; it's a (very) small business with a very direct relationship between items sold and revenue made. But each one is again key to understanding the story being told, fully integrated into comic. Who the fuck writes in second person? Dirk uses his position as the author to berate characters he doesnt like. Defending? I wish more people could tell the difference between art and the artist. Last year, the worlds S.U.V.s collectively released almost a billion metric tons of carbon dioxide. Whos fetish. hating her or not hating her and liking her as a character and oh my god can we please stop talking about Vriska). The entire story was one long, continuous block that Ive long since forgotten, spiraling through whatever settings kids would love to live in: outer space, ancient Egypt, the woods, the African Savannah, the world of Pokemon, magic, whatever. DISH network users facing authentication or login issues. The solid sales performance also lifted the food retailer's profit margins. Regardless, the intense gaze of the man in the thumbnail dares you to go on and see what the hell this is all about. To learn more or opt-out, read our Cookie Policy. In addition to music, most pages at minimum combine text and images, but gifs and Adobe Flash animations are common. Jade was one of my favorite characters. Not in the game, so I don't care. As for Karkat using "autistic" as an insult did he really? 15 jan 2023 08:41:30 Why Perhaps youll click the first. At this point in the web-comic, they fix Tavros. Debunking the "Hussie is terrible" Google Docs link : r/homestuck She takes her time, narrating with a kind of dry, verbose voice. Why Sprouts Farmers Market Stock Jumped This Week Cyberduds. or have experienced the same thing? And then theres this game in the mail. Submit fanart, cosplay and discussions of all kinds! We have different media, slang, food, hobbies, etc, so Hussie's references soared straight over my head. It is easy to wonder how connected the two things are, and to wonder why one of the very, very few disabled characters has to also be a social outcast. Take later. There exists a possibility of me being a pizza. WebIts likely that managers who say, bring me solutions, not problems dodge complaints and criticism to avoid time-consuming conflicts and tiresome tension. As it goes in the story, she was drunk driving, and after the cop gets physical with her, she grabs the gun from his holster and shoots. This is not so much directed at you, fiveforchaos, but since this sort of misconception comes up frequently I figured I might as well step in. He is, by my estimation, the most interesting part of either epilogue, anyway. A hole in plot, if you will. We are currently experiencing a system-wide issue with a delay on all activations. Accusations of certain characters beings Mary Sues. Maybe it would help if I knew what "AAVE" is, though. Actually, my favorite thing about the webcomic: Homestuck is acutely aware that it exists on the Internet, and exploits that fact to its fullest capacity. But how much is that purpose worth? Homestuck is also filled with blind jokes. When users affected by the problem try to access the DISH network system, all they get is a System is currently Theres also the fact that the epilogues have no qualms about crushing aspects of the story the reader may have enjoyed. Firstly, there is no total concensus within the text or with the characters. The SFW hes the stereotype of a transman. She is the only female (and carapacian) member of the Felt, and is one of the three members whose name is not printed entirely in green, the "o" being printed in black to resemble an 8 ball itself. If you are talking about, Karkat: hey asshole, stop playing games for girls, then I see it differently from you. Hell no. Both options ultimately leave someone somewhere dissatisfied. A decade in the future, long after our heroes win the game, and long after our heroes have left Homestuck itself, John is confronted with a choice: he can use his powers to return to canon, fill the plot hole, and stabilize the story, or decide to continue living his life, canon integrity he damned. Point 4: Explanation and justification are not the same. Homestuck Point 1.5: Many of the arguments presented in the document hinge on the idea that inclusion means approval (see Point 1). Why it matters: Silvergate had an unusually strong balance sheet but that wasn't enough to save it because in today's high-rate And then they win the third time, after John rewrites the story to make that happen, and finally get to go to a new universe and live happily ever after. Apparently some things Hussie produced in the past were fairly misogynistic/racist, and there's some debate over what Hussie's current opinions are. Meat, like Lord English, is already here. The Homestuck Discord exists at https://discord.gg/homestuck if you want to chat with fellow fans. What the actual fuck are you talking about? I think one of the most impressive things about the webcomics music is how much of it there is (a lot of much there is, thats how much). Could things have been done differently for better effect? Hussies apprehension of fandom and the wild projections that come with presiding over one seem appropriate given how public comments on his work ignite controversy within the fandom. Johns relationship with Terezi, which really only existed in the last 50 pages of the comic, was apparently always the better option? Like I oughta. Also, (controversy incoming) in my honest opinion, as long as you don't have children, there's nothing wrong about incest. Although dogfighting is a felony in all 50 states and the District of Columbia, Guam, Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands, it continues to occur in every part of the country and in every type of community. Half of his comments are "N-NO, YOU?" ._1W1pLIfaIb8rYU6YeTdAk6{margin-right:6px}._1H6Meh6ZAemKxOJDOEasfK{border-radius:50%;box-sizing:border-box;height:20px;margin-left:-8px;width:20px}._1H6Meh6ZAemKxOJDOEasfK:first-child{margin-left:0}._30vlMmCcnqKnXP1t-fzm0e{display:inline-block;margin-left:-8px;position:relative} ALL trolls have horns. The only reason people are so attached to the original joke is because it was taken away from them. And then theres Cronus, a 19 year old, hitting on his dead descendant who is also 13. WebThis process, known as review-bombing, has been used for both good and bad causes. Personally, whatever his previous works may have been, I think he's done a wonderful job creating a wide variety of strong female characters. If not for the fact they made her into a Jewish stereotype. WebPhillip Faraone/Getty Images. Lynera is literally stalking Bronya, trying to control her relationships, and threatening those who get inbetween. Maybe you watched a lot of Naruto, so your big project is filled to the brim with edgy ninjas and impractically sized swords. I'm part of the tumblr community and several others. I saw a lot of promise in Johns relationship with Roxy. WebHomestuck has three characters with definite disabilitiesTavros, Terezi, and Solluxthough for the purposes of this article, I will focus on Tavros and Terezi as, ever since Sollux has become blind, we simply have not had much screen time with him to merit analysis Elwurd, who was allegedly based on the bi girlfriend of a male developer. It is problematic in that it presents characters with unlikeable traits in a positive light, problematic in the way it jokes about very serious subjects like abuse and murder, problematic in that it includes discriminatory language throughout the text, problematic in that oodles of teased ships are 'creepy' due to the age and/or percieved age and/or other factors Problematic like The Iliad, like Hannibal, like The Wire, like, The Shining, Lolita, Dracula, and so many other pieces of classic media. The Google docs had like 2 or 3 good points and the rest is just bullshit. If you actually read Hussie's tumblr about that incident, you would see that he specifically changed it not because people were upset about it but because other people on tumblr were using the canonicalization of tricksters as white to be nasty to others and he didn't want anything to do with that. No one considered it a slur yet. Homestucks saturation of timeline and narrative chicanery means that there are always multiple versions of each character that exist somewhere in the story, probably even at the same time. Set aside time just as you would for reading every novel, but be prepared to set aside much more of it. The epilogues were poorly received among some fans for a variety of reasons. Reading Homestuck is no easy feat, and will take a large amount of time. I see that like "are you crazy? That having been said Alternia, at least to me, was supposed to be some kind of dark joke about society; I mean their Jesus upon the moment of his crucifixion started cursing everyone out because they're just so shitty. So, you are saying I can't write about people who are not me? Like the story isnt coy about it. Chances are Hussie changed it in part because he wasn't really feeling the joke in the first place. SBaHJ is hailed as hilarious by being so INTENTIONALLY awful. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. than to disturb the comfortable and comfort the disturbed. Yes, but so are the men. So to that end I'd like to know what events caused the biggest splash with fans. Heck, people are still debating troll genitalia). Copyright issues; unlike many, more mainstream (and powerful) content producers who kind of give convention artists alleys the big shrugaroo, a small buisness like What Pumpkin LLC, the company that sells Homestuck merchandise, does not have the luxury of being able to afford turning a blind eye to fan produced content, and is thus very strict about people selling fanmade Homestuck content. I don't think people give the tumblr community enough credit for how much creative content it produces, but they are right that the SJW side can get a little over the top. "umm that karkat is problematic? And then they have a kid who she abuses. OK, but how is that racist? I don't agree with the original doc, but yes, OP wrote a terribly annoying post. They post in the most inappropriate moments, for example, a tragedy happened, and all of a sudden a K-Pop post pops up in the replies not once but many, many times. From a human perspective, she's an unmistakably gay character. Homestuck /*# sourceMappingURL=https://www.redditstatic.com/desktop2x/chunkCSS/UsersCountIndicator.2ab8dda40f822a31d31c_.css.map*/to which I say yes. As both of the characters are canonically gay many people consider it erasing their sexuality to put them in heterosexual pairings in fanfic. First, Tavros Nitram is treated abhorrently in Homestuck; his disability (he is in a wheelchair, paralyzed from the waist down) is oftentimes depicted in a hilarious way to try and make the audience laugh. What Pumpkin LLC is the business in question, not Andrew himself. 36.87%. In Meat, the story blasts through at a lightning pace, but the characters we love get thrown into the background as the story concerns itself more and more with Dirk and Calliope. The mock content warnings that show up at the beginning of the epilogues are not mock anything She spends extra time on characters feelings and their conversations with each other, much to the annoyance of Dirk. Damara speaks in broken english, and her japanese is straight from google translate. Was it really an insult? The figure of revolution in the eyes of Hussies story is in fact, an influencer. Example: MLP makes money not only by merchandising but also by ad sales, etc. And the world ends. The fact that Andrew Hussies Homestuck is terrible is an immutable fact I am stating for the record. In the final act of Homestuck were told the artifact defeats Lord English, and were told he dies after getting sunk in a black hole. And thats always something worth giving credit for, in my book. And then theres this whole other universe filled with aliens, Trolls, who already played it. Like how Vriska, a character who spent the entire comic inserting herself into important story events in a quest to become the most important character of the narrative, ends up trapped in Candy, locked away forever from canon. WebHomestuck tends to congregate in large groups that can cause problems at conventions. We did investigate it. Feferi's weight. They obviously "matured" when dead. This event kickstarts her own story and accelerates the development of her own personal politics. Yes, Vriska did that. I like my complaints like I like my inception, always going one level deeper. Homestuck is honestly a sprawling epic I mean, kind of. Cart; chantelle jamieson married Thats no way to handle an issue like this. And then Obama shows up. We are currently experiencing a system-wide issue with a delay on all activations. How to Read Homestuck: 8 Steps (with Pictures) - wikiHow The first Game of Thrones book is just shy of 300 thousand words, and the longest book in that series is just over 400 thousand. Apple @ Work: Why Wi-Fi 6E solves a major problem for IT Silvergate Banks balance sheet problem is a warning People generally overlook when boys are sexualized, (examples, all the shirtless art of the boys of BNHA, the entire Free series, etc.). While the "fat!Vriska" joke is still prevelant in the fandom, Vriska tends to be portrayed as fairly skinny in the fanart, and it's Ferferi who's often drawn as fairly chubby (as is Jane, but she's a bit less controversial). Sure, their bodies didn't change, but don't you dare say ghosts don't mature mentally. He forces Rose to consent to being kidnapped, then makes her wife, Kanaya, blame herself for it all. Wo Long: Fallen Dynasty is the latest product to feel the review bomb burn. Theres a problem with activations getting backed up, & stuck in our system. Kismessitudes really were just abusive relationships (we never saw a healthy example, the "dead ringer" of a black romance, Spades Slick and the troll's Black Queen, has BQ stab Slick in the eye and cut off his hand and Slick later shooters her. EVERYONE IS DEAD). Snowman God I cant stand moral guardians like that. The Bold Glamour filter acts as a reminder not to do the same when it comes to our faces. Some may argue that this forces the comic to be perpetually out of date, but Id argue the opposite. Hi. The Homestuck epilogues attempt to answer questions surrounding what canon is, and if the distinction between canon and Homestucks wealth of fanfiction is even significant to consider. Anyone who presides over something popular is forced to play the role of an informal cult leader, which is what it felt like throughout most of Homestucks run, and even well beyond. He said, Some online personalities will revel in that role, and actually start behaving like a true cult leader. For the Beta Kids, it's Jade, for the Trolls it's Vriska, and for the Alpha kids it's Dirk. No Disney-style moral to repeat to your children. Is it racist? Okay so later John says nominally Jake is indeed not at fault for being abused but appreciate for a moment how a story about kids playing a computer got to this point. While many people inside the Homestuck fandom thought this was an excellent and humorous reward (especially considering they got all the other rewards below it as well) people outside of the comic fandom didn't get the joke and thought it was an example of Hussie being and egomanical jerk. In fact, you yourself just said that "Japanese highschool girl esque- outfits" are sexual. But the comic you included in the docs is dumb and makes no sense to me. Post-Scratch Troll society is not presented as good. Music is even baked into the comics mechanics. Thewhirlwindofanarticledropsyou on a plush cushion of narrative airexactlywhereyoustarted,butolder,wiser,andaround whole20 minutesshorterontime. What Is Dogfighting, Why Does It Still According to multiple reports, many users of DISH network services are facing issues during the authentication or login process to the companys platform. Why "Queer Eye" star Karamo Brown recently told INSIDER that he thinks the beloved film about a gay relationship, " Call Me by Your Name ," is "problematic as f---." Media can be challenging, but largely it offers a totally safe place for people to indulge, express and investigate ideas they would NEVER do in real life and therefore does NOT always reflect an individual's real life views. and i think its mostly to do with homestucks treatment of femininity vs masculinity in a way that is not typically done The Meat timeline is obviously canon, because for Lord Englishs demise to make any sense, John needed to have gone back and plugged in the missing parts of the story. Her Imperious Condescension is one of the most notable victims of hussies blatant racism. In her article, How Twitter can ruin a life Emily VanDerWerff tells the story of an anonymous writer turned enemy of the internet, and how just a pseudonym and a birth year gave people on Twitter enough fuel to bully the author out of writing. 2. Fuck you. There are pages that break the style of the website, pages that change the CSS are common, and there are pages that change their formatting to fit different content. The counterargument to this is that John, the only character who is 100% confirmed to be canonically straight is very frequently paired with Dave and Karkat. WebA tale about a boy and his friends and a game they play together. As are the characters. As Dirk ascends, though, he gains full awareness of the story itself. This is basically what I did, and these two ideas mix together in the narrative., Prior to releasing this story, Hussie struggled to pinpoint what his brand was as the creator of Homestuck. Why Artist and writer Andrew Hussie is a reluctant father of internet fandom. I can only say that theyre interesting to consider if you happened to have read them. What video games and movies dont depict correctly is the insane recoil automatic fire causes. You know where else that happens? The music from this one little animation tells the story just as much as anything on screen does. With the end of Adobe Flash on the horizon, hours of Flash content, much of it interactive, is going to have to be scrapped and remade. It's a violent as hell culture created for a single purpose: victory. When people say BUT TEREZI MAKES FUN OF HERSELF, it is not really a valid defense of the blind jokes, because of who is actually making those jokes. He's an asshole and I can't stand him. Hussie suggests the personal allegorical elements in Psycholonials are more like points of inspiration. This story is about Z after all, not himself. Gross Margin. (As he puts it, its about the things its about.) The story presents a modern path to revolution in which the catalyst for the overthrow of an imperialist system is not the military strongmen of old, but a young woman with social media savvy. Im a shipper at heart I mean I like reading well-developed relationships. I mean it is a book, so it technically is porn? You must have a lot of time on your hands to look into all that, don't you? Web1,362,830. Mabye I am just dumb, but I didn't notice. Constantly seeking out fetishistic situations and sexualizing characters in a fantasy story as well reading straight up bullshit from in-between the lines. Doesn't that make you the racist one here? what problematic homestuck character are you Sure, I guess. Okay, so the plot hole is also a cue ball and the whole story is pool and chess and I think blackjack. Especially assholes brazen enough to supply your own thoughts to you with a subtle perspective shift from first to second person. OK, so who cares how old they were when they died? Why Homestucks Disaster of an Epilogue was so Bad - YouTube Webwho were victoria winters parents. Cool post though :). N/A. Or Faygo. But Homestuck isn't about fan inclusion for the sake of happy-fun-creating together, it's about WHY we might want to do that and a host of other things. Question: do thirteen year old girls have boobs? The 10,000 dollar donors for Hussie's kickstarter. If you dont write often and consequently dont think of story length in terms of word count (what are you, a normal person? We apologize for this Fanfiction that places Dirk and Kanaya in heterosexual pairings. Why Point is there are lots of the same character running around always. Andrew Hussie Vriska and Terezi were close friends during their childhood, who on Alternia formed the Scourge Sisters, Team Charge's FLARP rivals. Stelsa should only be written by someone Jewish. Homestuck is two or three biggish novels' worth of illustrated text, Homestuck uses Flash, which means that it has cough Cronus cough. It wasn't even that funny! To start, the music created in the making of, and parallel to Homestuck is simply incredible. Why Moreover, it occurs over and over again, too. The difference should be obvious, Devils advocate here: She's small, not neccesarily young. There are some aspects of Homestuck that deserve a deeper analysis and deconstruction than I can give here. The mysteries. Every bit of it is there in order to prepare the troll kids for the game. Music is so integral to the experience of Homestuck Id argue the story doesnt work without it. WebMuch of Problem Sleuth's success can be ascribed to an audience's willingness to accept that all the weirdness is just part of the joke, and the next logical step that we see in Homestuck, where the Internet itself becomes raw material for narrative, allows for an even greater expansion of possibilities. Im not sure if fondly is the word Id use here, but I can regard it. But Homestuck wouldnt be Homestuck if not for Hussies tendency to add more when in doubt, so here we are. there are pedophilic implications between Chahut who is confirmed to be basically an adult, soon to be taken off the planet and Amisia, a literal child, these were done by the same artist. Please explain. WebThis kind of perspective on friendship in the internet age is a big part of why Homestuck is rather progressive in its views of interpersonal relationships the relationships among characters are never downplayed because of the medium that they happen in, and its a refreshing take in a world that is constantly tut-tutting the idea of talking to strangers. Dividend Yield. Still, Hussie doesnt think every aspect of fandom is completely horrible. Some forms like writing fanfiction or creating fan art are a positive, fun activity. Can you imagine what my first attempts at writing looked like? Why didn't you mention that one? 1,362,830. But maybe that's just my take. The Meat/Candy dichotomy is one Hussie developed for himself long before the release of the epilogues. I have no official connection with the work. I will just go ahead and read through the Google Docs about Hussie being terrible and comment every time I have something to say. He would commandeer a handful of characters, and I do the same. Perhaps the epilogues are an attempt to have the reader live a moment in the life of Andrew Hussie. They eventually date in Candy, but it turns into a lopsided, unhealthy marriage and subsequent that prevents him from fully processing the fact that he is trans. problem And then one of the four kids, John, gains the ability to rewrite the comic itself. But, there is still no ETA for everything to work normally again. It was a joke/was supposed to be weird/the character doing the thing was supposed to look bad for it. After that page was posted, people (mostly from Tumblr) started a bit of an uproar, so Hussie retconned that page to say "PEACHY" rather than Caucasian. Dirk, though, happens not to subscribe to Uncle Bens mantras about power and responsibility. Hussie is a white man. Homestuck feels like a glorified, expensive, vaguely ornery version of my childhood game. Time to be controversial here. Its digitally illustrated and lets you click through like you would in a narrative game. Every single one of those tags appears somewhere in the story, including but not limited to: unhealthy relationships, graphic depictions of violence, transphobia, rape, major character death, and (may God help us all) eggs. Maybe the Twilight fan found a way to elevate the themes and feel of YA urban fantasy to an older audience. And then the monsters came. And then they got in a rocket.. Given the comics exponential trajectory it set for itself early on, it had to get this meta at some point. As the community got larger, and Hussie wanted more control of the story, this eventually petered out, which did distance some of the older problem sleuth fans. This Mo Black guy seems to know what hes talking about, you think. The NSFW route, hes a complete douchewad, bullying Lynera and trying to pressure you into drugs and sex. Be prepared. March 3, 2023. The single most respectful moment in Terezis portrayal is when she has the opportunity to have her blindness cured. DISH network users facing authentication or login issues. Come on, you disappoint. More detailed content warnings for The Homestuck Epilogues WebHomestuck has never shied away from cartoonish gore and bloodshed before, but ironically, what the epilogues lack in pictures they make up for in graphic content. Im not even going to get into their relentless support of ikimaru, the terrible treatment and handling of canonically gay characters, the overall grossness of the quadrant system, Another epilogue has been released as an official fanfiction, some of the tags are jokes, some are not, and im personally not at all interested in finding out which is real and which arent. Here appears another symptom of ableismthat of the view that persons with disabilities need to be fixed in order to fit in with normal society. This is just a single example of how bootleg items (because yes, even if they're being made with love and sold with respect for the original creator, they are bootleg items) can directly influence a small business' decisions and bottom line. I feel like you had "better" things to say than I did. Yet were given both to read. Like this the view I got in laravel 8 Laravel 8 paginate UI. Oh that's what you meant. by Your Name' Is Problematic Rose and Roxy. I don't think writing off the whole webcomic as worthless because it's 'problematic' is smart either. Do trolls even have races? The solid sales performance also lifted the food retailer's profit margins. Submit fanart, cosplay and discussions of all kinds! Why There is no denying that. For this specifically, theres nothing wrong with Mallek himself, its moreover how hes treated. Or perhaps the second option catches your eye. And she decides what gets put in front of our eyes and what doesnt. Remember how Lanque is trans? Wo Long: Fallen Dynasty is the latest product to feel the review bomb burn. It's pretty long. Why S.U.V.s Are Still a Huge Environmental Problem Each event sprouted up at random from our imaginations and was tacked on to the end of what we had with an and then. The lesson here is that an abuse victim needed to learn to take life into their own hands sooner. Towards the end of the main story, the comic introduces (and fails to develop) the idea of the Ultimate Self: characters with full knowledge and the full lived experiences of every character that has ever existed. This applies to the treatment of Mituna, who due to the overexertion of his psychic powers received brain damage that altered his personality. And then theres this gang war between these black alien mobsters, the Midnight Crew, and a time gang, the Felt, whos boss, Lord English is destined to destroy the multiverse.