This article is from the March/April 2020 issue of Combat Handguns magazine. Striker-Fired Subcompact Pistol . What works for one person might not work for someone else. But remember, every shooter is different — go with an option that works for you. The PPQ .45 does not come with Walther's typical paddle mag release but they've decided to go with the M2 or American style button release. Note: 15 is a perfect score for each category while 105 is a perfect total score. The shooter faces two target stands 8 yards away (with two cardboard targets sandwiching a “no-shoot target”) and a Birchwood Casey World of Targets Popper in the center at 10 yards. Don’t take that as a negative. The P99 also features a decocker button to put the pistol back to the double action pull. Arguably, HK’s modern handgun of choice today is the VP9. While the manufacturers offer various sighting arrangements as options, the Glock, Sig and Walther stood out with their AmeriGlo, SIGLITE and TruGlo tritium sights, respectively, making them highly visible in low-light conditions. However, for this comparison, I’m giving the advantage to the VP9. I own a lot of handguns and love trying as many as I can, but I am hard-pressed to tell you of one that’s this nice out of the box at any price. 308.3 Umarex Feuerwerk-Adapter. It's a real tack driver too. Typ P - 3 Stk. ...they have never been adopted by a major military (at least since WWII). As far as Walther products, I own a PPQ Navy, PPS M2 but also the Walther PPX M1 SD and now the Creed. As far as reliability, worst case scenario, Walther has recently implemented a lifetime warranty across their entire product line were things to go south....So the value is there. You’ll love it. The HK only came in last because its long trigger stroke caused some rounds to wander away from the intended point of impact. The fit was tight and trigger amazing (LGS). If that wasn’t possible, the pistol would be scored up to that point and then put aside while we finished testing the remaining handguns. strike fired systems. Again, there are plenty of great 9mm carry handgun option on the market. Walther is used by police forces the world over. Heckler & Koch began developing the USP in 1988 as a replacement for their unique but also aging P7 series of pistols. Seit über vier Jahrzehnten produziert UMAREX am Stammsitz in Arnsberg Freizeit- und Sportwaffen in hoher Qualität. Outstanding firearm with the Walther Anti Stress trigger and flush side mounted de cocker. While your VP9 may "feel" stronger, it is not. Here are a couple of common questions we see people asking on the Internet regarding what the best 9mm pistol is, especially as it relates to concealed carry. Richard seconded that because of the Walther’s sights and the fact that the grip fit his small hands much better. In addition, the pistol had a magazine capacity of eight rounds, which was higher than most other pocket pistol of the same calibre at the time. As in past “Battle Royales,” my friends Dick Jones and Richard Cole joined us for the range session, and we decided on the following drills: In this drill, the shooter begins facing 12 steel plates painted alternately white and blue. Which brings us to the subject of this “Battle Royale.” I decided to pit today’s most popular 9mm duty pistols against each other to see which one would come out on top at the range. 45 épingles • 7 abonnés. I have had AMAZING experiences with Walther P99s and now have several. It wasn’t long before duty revolvers became quite scarce, replaced by “wonder-nine” semi-autos from Beretta, Sig Sauer, Smith & Wesson, Walther and other companies. Settling between the Walther PPQ vs VP9 is the devil's own job, because each of the pistols has almost identical specifications. I have always been a little confused on Walther. Very recently, Walther seems to have decided to turn this around with the S&W/Walther "divorce". More of a backup. Some of this can be pinned on their American distributors, but I think if the home office cared about U.S. commercial sales enough, they would have found a way to make them happen. I have generally been under the impression that HK and SIG (though that might be changing) are considered to make the best consistent quality production handguns (not custom/$2000). While I have never fired one at the range, upfront opinions seemed to be on point. Accurate and great trigger with minimal reset. On the signal, they draw their pistol and double-tap each target and then shoot the Popper. But it is accurate and works. [citation needed] Founded by Carl Walther in 1886, the company has manufactured firearms and air guns at its facility in Germany for more than 100 years.Walther Arms, Inc. is the United States Walther business unit and is based in … How can the VP9 compete with a gun that won the competition to … I, myself have also considered a Walther. The FN’s magazine release received some criticism as being a bit difficult to manipulate, and it was unanimous that the Sig’s grip frame was too narrow. We ended up expending over 2,000 rounds of ammo generously donated by Black Hills Ammunition (black-hills.com). A number of Walther models being produced by companies other than Walther —i.e. The simplicity, affordability and practicality of polymer-framed pistols have made them the handguns of choice among U.S. law enforcement agencies. Introduced in January 1990, it quickly displaced the 9mm pistols used by most departments, and the .38 and .357 revolvers still in service. Factory ammo is perfect, throat is a bit tight for some of my reloads (150gr)but that is my issue, not really the gun's. This is a very personal call, but the S&W only lost one point, and the Walther was a single point behind it because one shooter felt the grip was too short and didn’t care for the finger grooves. The modern Walthers that are actually made by Walther are outstanding products. Five of the guns have magazine releases located in the “proper” position and are either ambidextrous or could be easily switched from left to right sides, but again, the HK differs in that its release is an ambidextrous paddle located under the triggerguard. Actually better than most gloves. We’ll get there. This means that the HK is the only gun in the shootout with an external hammer. Once again, the Glock, S&W and Walther tied in this category, with the FN and HK trailing by a mere point each. The CCP M2 handgun series represents the next step in the pursuit of perfection at Walther. HK VP9 vs Walther PPQ. The guns included the FN 509, Glock 17 Gen5, Heckler & Koch P30, Sig Sauer P320 Full-Size, Smith & Wesson M&P9 M2.0 and the 5-inch-barreled Walther PPQ M2. Once we had all the test pistols in hand, my wife, Becky, and I zeroed each model from an MTM K-Zone rest at 15 yards. But my opinion may not be entirely objective, I have never been into Glocks, S&W M&P, and other similar types of pistols. Walther Ppq Online Shop mit großer Auswahl | Hier Walther Ppq auf Rechnung bestellen im Frankonia Onlineshop! The KH VP9 is slightly larger, which accounts for it weighing just over 1 ounce more than the Walther PPQ. The HK’s DA/SA trigger came in for the usual complaints as the DA pull was quite heavy and the SA pull had a long take-up. First produced in 2014, the VP9, called the Volkspistole or people’s pistol became one of the company’s most popular pieces ever. Currently, the .40 is the most widely used police handgun cartridge in the nation, although it appears that situation is changing. Note: If you’re on a mobile device, you may need to scroll to the right to see the complete results in the table below. They’ve gone from a simple target rifle manufacturer in the 1880s to now being one of the most famous firearms manufacturers in the entire world. The special thing about Walther … Ceased production after WW2: Walther PPK. For purposes of clarity, I consent to Athlon's collection, storage, processing, and transfer of my Personal Data and Non-Personal Data (as defined in the Privacy Policy) for the purpose of signing up for the email newsletter. Once again pushing beyond the boundaries of expectations to meet this demand, Walther released the extraordinary CCP M2 9mm pistol. We … They hold the same number of rounds, and they basically cost the same amount of money to buy. A PPQ M2 chambered in 9mm to be exact. So yes, it is ‘just another striker fired 9mm pistol’ on the market. Five of the pistols come with interchangeable backstraps, and the HK goes one step further by allowing shooters to replace the side panels as well for a truly customized grip frame. P.S. Then, thanks to growing urban violence in the 1960s, many police agencies switched to more powerful .357 Magnum revolvers. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. From 8 yards, he lifts his pistol and engages the white plates until they’re all are down, then performs a combat reload and engages the blue plates. Compare Views. Lol!!! The shooter faces three steel targets at 10 yards. These were then added together to give each pistol a final score in each category, with 15 being a perfect score. All six shot to the point of aim and produced groups ranging from 1.75 to 2.25 inches, which we felt was more than satisfactory for their intended purpose as police/defensive handguns. Walther produces an assortment of high-quality handguns for law enforcement, military, and civilians alike. On the other, people say that their design/fit and finish is top notch, but their long term durability/adverse conditions reliable has never matched HK/SIG. I can only vouch for the ones I'm personally familiar with---the PPQ, P99AS and P38/P-1 are top notch weapons. I have owned both and HK is the only brand I still own. Fit, finish, quality and that are-you-seriously-telling-me-this-is-stock Walther trigger are exactly what you’d expect. (Yes, that’s polarizing – one man’s HK is another man’s Sig, etc) While the HK 416 22 is more or less a .22LR AR available as both a pistol and a rifle, “more and less” would be a better description. The HK VP9 sports a 4.09-inch barrel, with a total length of 7.34 inches. Finally, as befits pistols designed for police service, all six have rails for mounting lights, lasers and other tactical accessories, and they all weighed less than 30 ounces unloaded, making them comfortable for all-day carry. The drill is repeated three more times. The S&W and Walther tied here thanks to their triggers’ short take-ups and crisp let-offs. The others use strikers for ignition. I don't carry the glock, it is a night drawer gun with a laser on it. 310.100 Umarex Ladehilfe. The Walther is a very good quality pistol, but even taking its plastic sights and guide rod out of the equation, it doesn’t feel like quite the pistol the HK is. As for me, I have to admit that it was awfully close to being unanimous, but in the end, I went with the S&W. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! The score is the total time for the four runs plus a five-second penalty for any miss. We follow conformity assessment procedures that comply with directive 2014/68/EU (Pressure Equipment Directive) to ensure that we can react to special customer requests with great flexibility. While the Walther had superior sights to me, I felt the S&W’s ergonomics and trigger were the best of the lot. Now the ppq is my carry gun. They then perform a combat reload and repeat the drill. I have no regrets at all only wish I had done it sooner. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window), POF Minuteman: The 10.5-Inch Barreled 5.56mm NATO Pistol, Springfield Hellcat OSP: Carry Pistol Adds Manual Ambi-Safety, Lone Wolf LTD: Glock-Pattern G19-Sized Pistol for Concealed Carry, Blackhawk Stache: New IWB Holster Redefines Deep Concealment Gear, Bianchi Assent: Safariland’s Newest Concealment Holster Fits 250 Pistols, Winchester Defender Line Adds 5.56, 12-gauge & 20-gauge Loads, 82-Year-Old Vietnam Vet Beats Armed Intruder to Death With Shotgun Butt, 12-Year-Old Boy Grabs Gun, Shoots Intruders Who Shot His Grandmother, WATCH: Texas Mom Lays Out Alleged Peeper With Bone-Crushing Tackle, Taurus TX 22 Competition: Red Dot Mounts Directly to New Pistol’s Barrel. Before we do, I can remember a time when if you saw a police officer, you could have bet that their sidearm was a revolver. The FN’s sights were high and large for fast acquisitions and transitions between targets. It would have been a blued Smith & Wesson, Colt or Ruger wheelgun in .38 Special with a 4-inch barrel. The glock is a glock. The Target Barn and Competition Electronics provided ISPC cardboard targets and a Pocket Pro shot timer, respectively. The others use … Carl Walther GmbH Sportwaffen (German: ), or simply known as Walther, is a German weapon manufacturer, and a subsidiary of the PW Group. Whether the VP9‘s build quality will give it any advantage in the real world over a decade of hard use, I have no idea. I have the Magnum Research Eagle 9mm that I'm particularly fond of. I'd have no doubts about their reliability and would easily trust them for EDC. CCP M2. One also has to be aware of what is a "real" Walther and what is a Umarex Walther. You can also transform the pistol into carry, compact and subcompact configurations with the right grip module, barrel and slide. Before we left the range, I put my friends on the spot by asking which of our half-dozen test pistols would be their choice if they were law enforcement professionals. With their PPQ .45 ACP M2 they have now come for the American market. mit Gummipolster. Is there one “best” handgun? Eats my rounds, no issues fits my hand like a glove. The company won the tender and over the succeeding years, their reputation as quality weapon makers grew. WALTHER PILOT pressure tanks meet the strictest requirements as regards quality and safety. The HK and Walther pistols use 15-round magazines while the rest use 17-round magazines. Wir … This means that the HK is the only gun in the shootout with an external hammer. While the P99 was striker fired, it was unique in that the first trigger pull is long while all subsequent shots are short. The P99 was quite successful in Europe, but noticeably less so in the United States. In terms of operation, five are striker-fired designs while the HK P30 follows the beat of a different drummer with a traditional double-action/single-action (DA/SA) trigger system. We all noticed that the Glock tended to point high upon presentation while the HK’s paddle magazine release was just too different for shooters used to the more traditional positioning. While this is not offered on the Walther, some may prefer the trigger on this pistol over the H&K as it is seemingly lighter, crisper, and responsive to the touch with a much shorter reset. VP9SK . While the Walther was the only pistol with a perfect score in the accuracy category, all of them provided sufficient precision for their intended purposes. There are plenty of accurate 9mm pistol options out there. This extra weight had the effect of improving the shooting qualities and accuracy of the pistol. HK VP9 and VP9SK are more ergonomic and customizable than the Walther PPQ. The PPQ is simply an updated version of their previous P99 series of pistols. Copyright Complaints: Please direct DMCA Takedown Notices to the registered agent: http://www.defensereview.com/walther...stol-face-off/, https://lanzerbot.wordpress.com/2015...s-vp9-trigger/. VS. Heckler & Koch . HK is know for its outstanding quality and reliability.. shoot one before you say another word. It’s all subjective, though. Grab your copy at OutdoorGroupStore.com. The Walther PPS is one of the best "pocket pistols" around IMHO. Heck, even the magazines cost about the same amount. A historically conservative marketing strategy that seemingly placed little emphasis on North American commercial sales of full-size centerfire handguns. HK VP9 . For digital editions, visit Amazon. The HK and Walther pistols use 15-round magazines while the rest use 17-round magazines. They're excellent guns with excellent features. Handgun Search; Tabletop Compare; Contribute; Contact; Walther . … Before the CCP, the only available easy to rack handgun was the .380 ACP. P30. ...people say that their design/fit and finish is top notch, but their long term durability/adverse conditions reliable has never matched HK/SIG. The gun is 5.41 inches tall, and 1.32 inches wide. I do agree with the conclusions of this review though my new Creed has around 500 rounds through it with no problems and I have shot a greater variety … Here’s the “less:” The HK416 22 is a purpose built semi-automatic .22LR rifle (and pistol version, too) wrapped in AR15 style clothes. Works, but poor trigger as compared to either of the Walthers. HK has a slight advantage with their poly coat, but both guns look and feel great. für doppelreihige Magazine . Walther has consistently been producing high quality firearms since 1886 and many of their pistols are among the most iconic in the world, including the PPK, P38, and the P99. They're near as makes no difference the same size and weight. The others finished in the order they did because their releases were either difficult to access, difficult to operate, or their magazines occasionally failed to drop free. I have a PPX which is one of the ugliest handguns ever made, but has an outstanding trigger pull, is rifle accurate, and has never jammed once in over 4,000 rounds. In arguably the most packed field in the industry, we tested six full-size pistols to determine the best 9mm pistol side arms for law enforcement. walther 14.01.2020 Test: Walther Creed 9mm polymer-framed pistol, quality at the right price Creed – presented at the SHOT Show in 2017, that's what Carl Walther company called the successor model to its PPX. The next run is the same, except the shooter begins with the blue plates and then transitions to the white plates. Nicest "small" pistol I ever put my hands on. We then field-stripped, cleaned and lubricated each pistol—the only maintenance they received. The Sig got dinged for a few failures to feed and eject, and the FN failed to ignite eight different cartridges. I do agree with the comment that the ppx is the ugliest gun ever. Two shooters felt the Sig’s sights were too low. HK is know for its outstanding quality and reliability.. shoot one before you say another word. But dissatisfaction with the performance of early 9mm hollow-point ammunition led to calls for a more authoritative round, which resulted in the development of the .40 S&W cartridge. für Gas-Signal Waffen. Walther PPQ vs H&K SFP9/vp9 Collection de Seb. The .45 ACP followed suit in 1995, … So, yes I'm a Walther fan! The introduction of the Glock 17 began the so-called “polymer revolution,” and today, just about every handgun maker of note offers a “plastic pistol” suitable for police and military service. The German made Walther PPQ .45 is a superb pistol with a fit and finish that can proudly match up against any of the top gun makers. The FN’s trigger was more than acceptable but a bit gritty. I have read the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, and Cookie Policy, and I hereby agree to those terms. It seems that American shoote… On one hand their guns feel solid (to me in the LGS at least), and I hear few complaints overall, aside from one or two very … Compare the dimensions and specs of Walther CCP M2 and Heckler & Koch VP9SK. I'm a blued or stainless steel with wood grips kinda guy. The USP finished development in 1993 and the 9mm and .40 caliber versions were released to the public in 1994. Just my opinion. Walther PPQ vs HK VP9: Specs . To safely lower the HK’s hammer on a loaded chamber, you depress a serrated decocker on the backside of the slide. As can you can see in the included table, the Glock, S&W and Walther tied with perfect scores in the reliability department. And this particular Glock’s trigger was extremely gritty, which forced shooters to nurse it when shooting the plate racks and trying to avoid (unsuccessfully in a number of cases) hitting the no-shoot targets in the Nine + Nine Drill. The CCP – or Concealed Carry Pistol – is the first polymer pistol with … Sig Sauer has enjoyed a great reputation for many years, and for most of that time, this reputation was well-deserved. Lastly, while the Walther offers traditional 3-dot white sights, the H&K provides tritium night sights right out of the box that will illuminate with the intensity of a glow-stick in low-light settings, allowing for … I sold my glock 19 for the PPQ M1 mm and sold my Springfield XD 40 For the PPQ M2 40. In fact, both barrels measure right around 4 inches, with overall lengths of a little more than 7 inches. I've a ppq m2 9mm, Gen 3 glock 17, and a ppx 9mm. Walther is a gun company that always seems to introduce a new innovative feature with each gun they make. Walther ProSecur Trigger Lock. I own around 50 handguns, most of which are Glocks, Sigs and HK but I do like less expensive handguns that perform well. Interarms (Black Creek / Ranger) PPK and PPK/S in the 70s-90s; S&W PPK and PPK/S from the 90s until recently; and P22, PK380, and CCP by Umarex today. This all changed in 1985 when the U.S. Army adopted the 9mm Beretta 92 pistol as the M9. The Sig’s trigger had such a short take-up it felt more like a single action, which two of us felt was too light for a pistol intended for police service, especially since there is no other external safety. These two 9mm pistols come with very similar dimensions. Striker-Fired Subcompact Pistol *Buying ammo from LuckyGunner.com helps support HandgunHero. What’s the best 9mm pistol when talking about modern police sidearms? The PK380 is a Umarex Walther and not considered as up to "real" Walther standards. I had an S&W/Walther PPK/S awhile back. 302.60 Heckler & Koch Magazin. The Walther / Smith and Wesson PPS is way overrated . Probably if you take every review into account, but again, go with what works best for you. The Walther PPQis slightly older than the VP9, being released in 2011. None of us are fans of white-three-dot sights, so the HK and S&W both lost points. The HK USP series of pistols are, without question, some of the most thoroughly torture tested pistols in existence. Facing In; … The score is the total time for both runs plus a five-second penalty for any misses or “no-shoot” hits that are not made up. WATCH: How Does Home Defense Shotgun Ammo Really Penetrate Walls. Feb 20, 2020, Stay in the know with the Personal Defense World newsletter, Hellcat RDP: Springfield Unveils New HEX Wasp Red Dot Atop New Pistol, WATCH: Retired Chicago Fireman, Concealed Carrier Killed in Carjacking, Rep. Carolyn Maloney Drops the Mother of All Gun Control Bills, NICS Review Act: Maloney’s Bill Would Weaponize the NICS System, Gun News, Gun Reviews, and Self Defense Tips, You use of this website constitutes and manifests your acceptance of our. While some dared to suggest that semi-automatic pistols might be more practical police sidearms, these calls were considered so radical that they were generally ignored. I changed these out with Trijicon steel night sights and now its an A-One firearm. Consequently, my vote went to the pistol from Springfield, Massachusetts. Any of the manufacturers we tested here is a good start. 312.150 Umarex Schalldämpfer. Right off the bat, all six test guns have polymer frames and steel slides. Of course, the additional weight is negligible, and both come with 15, plus … The score is the total time for both runs plus a five-second penalty for hitting the wrong plate out of sequence or leaving one standing. It is a striker-fired polymer pistol that acts like a solid steel framed SIG. Finally, as in previous “Battle Royales,” each pistol was graded on a 1 (worse) to 5 (best) scale in seven categories: reliability, ergonomics, trigger control, recoil control, sights, off-hand accuracy and reloading ease. Much to the dismay of the traditionalists among us, this encouraged American police agencies to ditch their wheelguns and adopt higher-capacity 9mm pistols. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. For the P320, Sig offers three different full-sized grip modules, allowing you to replace the entire frame. In terms of operation, five are striker-fired designs while the HK P30 follows the beat of a different drummer with a traditional double-action/single-action (DA/SA) trigger system. Here the S&W and Walther tied again due to their easy-to-access magazine releases. If one malfunctioned during the face-off, we would attempt to correct the problem on site. ...is it just a result of them being a relatively small company. They don't call the PPQ M1 the World's Finest Handgun for no reason. The Glock and Walther owned this category thanks to their bright and fast-to-acquire AmeriGlo and TruGlo front sights. Your home defense shotgun may need to shoot through walls if the situation calls... by Frank Melloni / Customary Metric . And not as accurate. HK 416 AR Pattern .22. On the signal, he lifts his pistol and double-taps each target, then performs a combat reload and double-taps each once again. All of us felt that the texturing on the narrow Sig grip wasn’t aggressive enough, which allowed it to move around in our hands under recoil. The MR9 is basically a P99 with a little MR customization of the slide. Our certified quality and our sustainability make it possible to live up to this ambition. S. everyone should know the parts of a gun and how to break it down, clean it, reassemble, and fire it safely. Walther quality? Today, the HK VP9 competes with other handguns such as the CZ P10C, Glock 19, and the Walther PPQ. My only gripe is that is comes with plastic contrast sights. It rocks a 15 round magazine and weight 25.56 ounces with an empty magazine. Pros: A high quality, reliable pistol with some advanced features: Cons: Not very sexy looking. Dick said that while it was a difficult choice between the S&W and Walther, the latter won out thanks to its superior sights.